"... there's an inherent warmth to Everybody Knows. Stills and Collins have a gentle, easy chemistry and the studio-slick supporting performances provide a nice bed for a project that is less nostalgia than a reassuring reminder of the comfort of growing old together"

"Their voices blend together well, especially on the title song. The roughness of Stephen Stills' leathery vocals meshes well with Judy Collins' velvety crooning and fits the black humor of Cohen's lyrics ... Whether Stills & Collins have moved on or are lost in the past is all in the mind of the listener"